The early Spring here in the East gave me a chance to head for the yard and tool shed to see what projects were ready for the weekend. As I was looking over the garden tools, I came across the two pieces of a shovel I had broken last summer. This shovel had been in my family for over thirty years – a strong wooden handle, a great blade still without a spot of rust. But it was sadly now in two pieces, at long last a victim of attacking roots of one last stubborn and old shrub in the yard. I had forgotten about it over the winter, and was now remembering how hard it was to throw the pieces away last year.
My girlfriend asked, “that shovel is a Craftsman? I think it has a lifetime guarantee. You should check it out.” Indeed, my dad had bought a lot of tools from Sears over the years, but while I remember wrenches, pliers and screwdrivers from their Craftsman brand having the guarantee, it hadn’t dawned on me it would apply to garden tools too.
We drove to the local Sears store and headed it, shovel parts in hand. I had NO expectations or even any real hopes that they would replace the shovel. In fact, after owning the product for thirty something years, I was probably more concerned the sales person would either have a laugh or think I was nuts to even ask. I found the tools department, and approached the sales desk. “Can I help you?” asked a twenty-something. I was going to answer something to the effect that I had a shovel that was older than her that I had broken and would like to replace, but instead explained I had broken the shovel and wanted to see if they would honor the guarantee. “Sure, we’ll replace it. Let’s go pick out a new one.”, she replied. To my amazement, we went and found a new shovel, proudly displaying the Craftsman brand and with some great features I didn’t know shovels even had – guess thirty years will evolve even a shovel!
As for my twenty-something Sears advocate, there was nary a “hmm, I’ll have to check”, nor a “how did YOU break it?”, nor “I’ll need to file a claim – you’ll need to fill out these forms”. The answer was, is and always will be: “yes, we stand by our product, and we’re happy to have you be a satisfied customer.”
What was great about this experience:
- The PRODUCT guarantee was GENUINE – not just a punch line
- The BRAND guarantee was GENUINE – delivered with a smile by the front line
- The promise and the policy were rooted in a brand’s tradition – and forged to be unequivocal
Nordstrom has always been famous for its customer service, and there’s always been a potentially mythical but always powerful story about a store associate accepting a tire a customer returned to Nordstrom. And while Sears itself has had lots of ups and downs over the years, this Craftsman brand remains as steadfast as always. The POWER of the brand experience is to be surprising by honoring the brand promise – and in the process, create a memorable experience and a powerful brand story to tell many others about. I know where I will continue to buy tools for the trade and the yard. Good work Sears!



